The “How to” on Choosing the Right Storm Shelter for Your Family

September 16, 2025

When it comes to tornado safety, one of the biggest questions homeowners face isn’t “Do I need a shelter?” — it’s “Which shelter is right for me and my family?”


With multiple options available — above-ground, underground, garage-installed, or yard-installed — the choices can feel overwhelming. Add in the question of size (how many people your shelter needs to protect), and it’s easy to put off making a decision.



But here’s the truth: tornadoes won’t wait for you to decide. That’s why we’ve put together this practical guide to help you understand your options and choose the shelter that best fits your home, family, and lifestyle.


Above-Ground vs. Underground Shelters

The first choice most families face is whether to install an above-ground or underground storm shelter. Both are built to FEMA standards, both are engineered to withstand EF-5 tornadoes, and both can save lives. The difference comes down to accessibility, convenience, and your property’s layout.


🔹 Underground Shelters

Underground shelters are the classic choice. Installed below the ground, they offer maximum protection and stay out of sight when not in use.


Pros:

  • Shielded from flying debris and direct wind force.

  • Space-saving — blends seamlessly into your yard or garage floor.

  • Stays cooler in hot weather, offering comfort during extended sheltering.

Cons:

  • Requires stairs or a ladder to enter, which may not be ideal for elderly family members or those with mobility challenges.

  • In areas with high water tables, underground placement may be limited.

Best For: Families with larger yards, new construction builds, or homeowners who want a hidden, permanent shelter solution.


🔹 Above-Ground Shelters

Above-ground shelters are installed at ground level, either inside your garage or outside on a concrete pad. They’ve grown in popularity thanks to improved engineering and accessibility.


Pros:

  • Easy entry — no stairs, making them ideal for seniors, children, or people with mobility issues.

  • Quick access during sudden nighttime storms.

  • Can be placed in a garage, allowing families to stay dry while entering during heavy rain.

Cons:

  • Occupies visible space in a garage or yard.

  • May cost slightly more depending on customization.

Best For: Families who need accessibility, homeowners with limited digging space, or those in areas where underground placement isn’t possible.


Garage vs. Yard Installation

Once you’ve decided between above-ground or underground, the next question is where to install it. For most homeowners, the choice comes down to the garage or the yard.


🔹 Garage-Installed Shelters

Installing a shelter in your garage offers the ultimate convenience.


Why homeowners love it:


  • Fast access: No need to step outside in dangerous weather.

  • Discreet placement: Underground units sit flush with the garage floor, invisible when not in use.

  • All-weather entry: Stay dry while moving to safety during heavy rain or hail.

Garage installations are especially popular for families with children — when seconds count, you want the quickest path to safety.


🔹 Yard-Installed Shelters


For homes without garages or when garage space is limited, a yard-installed shelter is an excellent alternative.


Benefits:

  • Can be placed near the home for quick access.

  • Offers flexible sizing options, including larger-capacity models.

  • Ideal for rural properties with more open space.

Considerations:


  • Families must step outdoors to reach the shelter, which can be risky in sudden or nighttime storms.

  • Placement should balance easy access with safety — too far from the house, and it may be difficult to reach in high winds.

Choosing the Right Size

Another critical decision is size. A shelter that’s too small will leave family members uncomfortable — or worse, unprotected. A shelter that’s too large may be unnecessary for your household and property.


As a rule of thumb, FEMA recommends about 5 square feet per person in a storm shelter. Here’s a quick guide:


  • 4–6 Person Shelter (20–30 sq. ft.)
    Perfect for small families or couples. Compact, affordable, and efficient.

  • 8–12 Person Shelter (40–60 sq. ft.)
    Ideal for medium-sized families or households that want extra room for neighbors, pets, or visiting relatives.

  • 12–20 Person Shelter (60–100 sq. ft.)
    Designed for large families, multi-generational households, or community/group settings.

Don’t forget pets. Many families want to bring dogs or cats into the shelter during a storm. Factor in extra space for carriers, leashes, or crates if needed.


Other Factors to Consider

When deciding which shelter fits your needs, keep these additional factors in mind:


  • Accessibility: Do you or a loved one need wheelchair access or stair-free entry?

  • Budget: Storm shelters come in a range of sizes and prices.

  • Neighborhood Setup: Do you want extra capacity in case neighbors join you during a storm?

  • Future Plans: If you’re building a home, plan for a shelter that fits your long-term family size, not just today’s needs.


Real-Life Scenarios

To help you visualize the decision, here are a few examples:


  • Young Couple Building Their First Home: They opt for a garage-installed underground shelter, flush with the floor. Compact, out of sight, and ready for when kids arrive in the future.

  • Family of Five in a Home Without a Basement: They choose an above-ground garage unit so their kids don’t have to navigate stairs in the dark.

  • Rural Homeowners With Plenty of Land: They install a large-capacity yard shelter with room for extended family and pets, knowing they often host relatives during storm season.

Peace of Mind in Every Season

Whether you choose an above-ground or underground model, garage or yard installation, small or large capacity, the key is making the decision before the next storm hits.


Every year, families across tornado alley are caught unprepared, believing that a hallway or bathroom is “good enough.” The reality is simple: nothing protects like a purpose-built storm shelter.


By weighing your options now, you’re ensuring that when the sirens sound, your family already knows exactly where to go. No panic. No scrambling. Just safety and peace of mind.


Final Thoughts

Choosing the right storm shelter doesn’t have to be complicated. Think about your family size, your home’s layout, and your accessibility needs. Then select the option that fits your lifestyle best.


At StormVault Shelters, we help homeowners find the perfect fit every day — from compact garage units to spacious yard shelters. All of our shelters are engineered to meet FEMA standards and built to protect what matters most: your family’s life.


📞 Ready to explore your options? Visit stormvaultshelters.com or call us today to talk through the right shelter for your home.


September 16, 2025
From cost savings to family safety, here’s why the perfect time to add a tornado storm shelter is before you unpack in your new home.
The dangers of Fall tornadoes and how to prepare your family and property to get through the seaso.
August 19, 2025
When most people think about tornadoes in the Midwest, they imagine springtime storms sweeping across “Tornado Alley.” But in states like Kentucky, Illinois, and Indiana, Fall can be just as dangerous—sometimes even more so. In fact, research has shown that a “secondary tornado season” often ramps up from September through November , creating a unique set of risks for homeowners and families across the region.  This guide will walk you through why Fall is a particularly hazardous time, what makes tornadoes in Kentucky, Illinois, and Indiana so destructive, and how to prepare your household for the season ahead. Why Fall Tornado Season Matters in the Tri-State Region Spring isn’t the only time to worry about tornadoes. The National Weather Service has documented a clear pattern of increased tornado activity in the Fall months . Several factors combine to make this season especially risky in Kentucky, Illinois, and Indiana: Clashing Air Masses Fall is a season of transition. Cold, dry air from Canada collides with lingering warm, humid air from the Gulf of Mexico. This sharp contrast creates instability in the atmosphere—the perfect ingredient for severe storms and tornadoes. Stronger Jet Stream In Fall, the jet stream often dips farther south, providing the wind shear needed for storm rotation. That wind shear is what turns a thunderstorm into a tornado-producing supercell. Shorter Days, Earlier Darkness One of the most overlooked dangers of Fall tornadoes is that they often happen at night or during evening hours. With less daylight, tornadoes are harder to see, making warnings more crucial. Changing Weather Patterns La Niña and El Niño cycles can also impact tornado frequency. For example, La Niña years tend to bring more active Fall severe weather across the Midwest and Ohio Valley. Kentucky, Illinois, and Indiana: Why These States Are at Risk The Tri-State region sits at a geographic crossroads where Gulf moisture, cold Canadian air, and western weather systems converge. This means tornadoes here are both common and sometimes extremely strong. Kentucky has seen catastrophic late-season tornadoes, including the devastating December 2021 outbreak , which caused historic damage across the western part of the state. Illinois averages around 50 tornadoes per year, with several significant outbreaks recorded in November , including the EF-4 Washington, IL tornado in 2013. Indiana is also highly tornado-prone, with outbreaks in both spring and fall. The state’s flat terrain makes long-track tornadoes possible. Together, these states form a dangerous corridor for late-season severe weather. The Hidden Dangers of Fall Tornadoes While all tornadoes are dangerous, Fall tornadoes bring unique challenges: Surprise Factor – Many families let their guard down after spring, not expecting major tornadoes later in the year. Nighttime Storms – More Fall tornadoes occur after dark compared to spring, making them harder to spot and more deadly. Colder Weather Damage – Power outages during colder months can quickly become life-threatening due to loss of heat. Leaves and Debris – Fallen leaves can clog storm drains, worsening flooding during severe storms that accompany tornado outbreaks. How to Prepare for Fall Tornado Season Preparation is your best defense against the unexpected. Here are key steps homeowners in Kentucky, Illinois, and Indiana should take before the Fall storm season ramps up. 1. Create a Severe Weather Safety Plan Every family should have a plan for what to do when a tornado warning is issued. This includes: Knowing the safest place in your home (a basement or a small interior room on the lowest floor). Practicing tornado drills with children so they know exactly what to do. Establishing a communication plan if family members are separated. 2. Get Weather Alerts You Can Trust Because Fall tornadoes often strike at night, you may not see them coming. Don’t rely solely on outdoor sirens. Instead: Purchase a NOAA Weather Radio with battery backup. Sign up for local text alert systems . Install trusted weather apps that provide push alerts for tornado warnings. 3. Fortify Your Home While no house is tornado-proof, there are steps you can take to reduce risks: Trim trees and remove dead limbs that could become dangerous projectiles. Clear gutters and drains of leaves to prevent flooding. Reinforce garage doors, as they are often the weakest point in a home during high winds. If possible, install impact-resistant windows. 4. Stock an Emergency Kit Tornadoes often bring power outages and road closures. Your kit should include: Flashlights and extra batteries Bottled water and nonperishable food Blankets and warm clothing (critical for Fall tornadoes) First aid supplies and necessary medications A battery-powered phone charger 5. Consider a Storm Shelter For the ultimate peace of mind, many families in Kentucky, Illinois, and Indiana are choosing to install steel storm shelters . FEMA and ICC/NSSA-compliant shelters are designed to withstand EF-4 and EF-5 tornadoes—the strongest on record. Having a shelter means: You and your family are protected no matter when the storm strikes. Property value can increase, as buyers see the shelter as a life-saving feature. Peace of mind knowing you don’t have to gamble with basement safety if debris or structural collapse is a concern. What to Do During a Tornado Preparation is only half the battle—knowing what to do in the moment is critical. If You’re at Home Go immediately to your safe room or shelter. Avoid windows. Flying glass causes many injuries. Protect your head with a mattress, helmet, or heavy blankets. If You’re in a Vehicle Do NOT try to outrun a tornado in congested areas. If possible, safely drive at right angles to the tornado’s path. As a last resort, lie flat in a low ditch and cover your head. If You’re in a Public Building Follow posted tornado shelter signs. Stay away from large-span areas like gyms or auditoriums, which are more likely to collapse. After the Tornado: Recovery and Safety The aftermath of a tornado can be just as dangerous as the storm itself. Watch for hazards like downed power lines, gas leaks, and unstable structures. Check on neighbors , especially elderly or disabled individuals. Document damage for insurance purposes with photos and videos. Avoid driving unless absolutely necessary—emergency crews need clear roads. Key Historical Fall Tornado Outbreaks in the Region To understand the risk, it helps to look back at history: November 17, 2013 – Illinois & Indiana A massive outbreak spawned over 70 tornadoes, including an EF-4 that devastated Washington, IL. November 6, 2005 – Evansville, IN A nighttime tornado struck a mobile home park, killing 24 people in their sleep. December 10, 2021 – Kentucky One of the deadliest late-season outbreaks in U.S. history, producing a long-track EF-4 tornado that tore across western Kentucky, killing dozens and destroying entire towns. These events highlight why Fall tornadoes are not to be underestimated. Final Thoughts: Don’t Let Your Guard Down This Fall Kentucky, Illinois, and Indiana residents know spring tornadoes are serious—but Fall tornado season can be just as deadly. The unique mix of unstable weather patterns, stronger jet streams, and nighttime storms makes preparation vital. By creating a plan, staying alert, fortifying your home, and considering a shelter installation, you can dramatically reduce your risk and keep your family safe. Don’t wait until warnings start blaring. Now is the time to prepare—before the next storm comes rolling across the Midwest.
June 14, 2025
Discover what to look for when buying a home storm shelter in Kentucky, Illinois, and Indiana. Learn about FEMA standards, steel construction, installation tips, and cost to protect your family from tornadoes.